Lead generation platforms like Thumbtack, Angi (formerly HomeAdvisor), and Yelp charge you for every lead. Some charge per contact. Some charge per click. All of them get more expensive over time. And none of them build anything that belongs to you.
How Lead Platforms Work
You pay per lead — typically $15-$100+ depending on your trade and location. The lead goes to you AND 3-5 competitors simultaneously. You're paying for the privilege of racing to respond first.
Typical Cost Per Lead
| Trade | Cost Per Lead | Leads/Month | Monthly Cost |
|---|---|---|---|
| Plumbing | $25-60 | 15-30 | $375-$1,800 |
| Roofing | $30-80 | 10-25 | $300-$2,000 |
| Electrician | $20-50 | 15-30 | $300-$1,500 |
| HVAC | $25-70 | 15-30 | $375-$2,100 |
| Landscaping | $15-40 | 20-40 | $300-$1,600 |
And these are leads, not customers. Conversion rate from lead platform leads averages 15-25%. So you're paying $100-$400 per actual customer through these platforms.
The Ratchet Problem
Lead platforms increase prices over time. As more contractors join, competition for each lead increases, and the platform raises prices. You have no negotiating power because you depend on their pipeline.
Stop paying and the leads stop instantly. You've built nothing. No SEO. No brand presence. No website ranking. No repeat customer pipeline. You rented leads — you never owned a lead generation asset.
What a Website Costs in Comparison
A Bindingstone website: $149/month flat. No per-lead fees. No competition for shared leads. Every lead that comes through your website is yours alone.
Over 12 months:
- Thumbtack/Angi: $3,600-$24,000 (and rising)
- Bindingstone website: $1,788 (and generating leads forever)
Even if your website only generates 2-3 leads per month in the first year, the cost per lead drops below platform pricing by month 6. And unlike platforms, the website compounds — SEO improves over time, content accumulates, and leads increase while costs stay flat.
The Ownership Difference
When you pay Thumbtack, you're renting access to someone else's audience. When you invest in a website, you're building your own audience. Your SEO rankings, your blog content, your Google reviews, your schema markup — these are assets that appreciate. Platform leads are expenses that vanish.
Use Both (Strategically)
We're not saying never use lead platforms. They can be useful for filling gaps, especially when you're new. But they should supplement your website, not replace it. The goal is to shift your lead mix from 100% paid to 80%+ organic over time.
A website that generates its own leads is the most valuable marketing asset a small business can own. $149/month, everything included. Start your free trial.
Ready for a Floor That Lasts?
We Build, Host, and Run the Website. You Run the Business.